Why are some people satisfied with their work and others are not? Is it because of their compensation, perks, their career path or other reasons? Having answers to those questions are invaluable in organizing work, supporting engagement and productivity, and supporting employee well-being and happiness.

A new study published by the Institute of Labor Economics by Milena Nikolova at the University of Groningen, Brookings and IZA, and Femke Cnossen at the University of Groningen researched this issue and published some important findings.

The researchers are the first to explore the determinants of work meaningfulness. They report: “Specifically, using three waves of the European Working Conditions Survey, we show that autonomy, competence, and relationships explain about 60 percent of the variation in work meaningfulness perceptions. Meanwhile, extrinsic factors, such as income, benefits, and performance pay, are relatively unimportant. Meaningful work also predicts absenteeism, skills training, and retirement intentions, which highlights the concept’s economic significance.”

 Other studies relying on self-reported and experimental data have challenged the assumption that only monetary motivations matter in the labor market  In fact, one convincing piece of evidence for the intrinsic value of work is the enormous psychological cost of becoming unemployed, which by far exceeds income losses.

 The researchers contend that autonomy, competence, and relatedness are about 4.6 times more important for meaningfulness at work than compensation, benefits, career advancement, job insecurity, and working hours. Relatedness, they argue, which reflects supportive relationships with colleagues and superiors, emerges as the most important factor for work meaningfulness.

These findings highlight the greater salience of self-efficacy and intrinsic motivation for meaningfulness compared to objective working conditions and monetary rewards.

Second, the researchers show that perceptions of meaningful work have implications for labor economics because they meaningfully predict retirement intentions, absenteeism, and skills training. For example, they say, “a ten-point increase in work meaningfulness reduces absenteeism by about one day per year and raises the intended retirement age by 2.5 years, on average.”

Despite this research by economists and other research by organizational psychologists which come to similar conclusions, the majority of leaders in organizations and employers believe that compensation and perks are the best motivators for employee satisfaction in their work.

Also, the “Great Resignation” has shown us that the conclusions of this research are clearly connected to workers’ dissatisfaction with their jobs.

Ray's latest blog posts

Remembering an Unjust War–Iraq

How will we remember the Iraq War? First to make a declaration. I am a pacifist and against all wars. It’s an illusion to view them in terms of winners and losers. Everyone loses, particularly the civilians. I have had personal experience with war, as my family were...

Building Positive Character in Children and Adolescents

In recent times there has been widespread discontent and criticism of the leaders of institutions and organizations. The vast majority of the criticisms have not been about leaders’ competence or skills. They have been about their unethical and immoral/amoral...

Perfectionism Can Kill You

“Reaching for the stars, perfectionists may end up clutching at air,” famous psychologist David Burns warned.” There’s a strong probability you’re a perfectionist if you’ve ever sobbed over receiving a B+ or coming in second place....

Thanks to Our Obsession with SUVs, Pristine Nature is Crumbling

You’ve certainly seen this advertisement or social media video before: an SUV or light truck racing down a winding gravel road in the wilderness or parked right by the lake or on the beach. These kinds of vehicles are supposed to be “great” in...

The Rise of American Authoritarianism

Introduction There are disturbing signs that America’s strength as a democracy has weakened because of significant support for authoritarianism and an autocratic President Donald Trump. And while we think of autocratic states and dictatorships developing as a result...

Acts of Kindness Can Help People Suffering From Depression–Study

According to new research, those who experience depression or anxiety symptoms can aid their own recovery by helping others. In contrast to two other therapy approaches used to treat depression or anxiety, the study found that practising acts of kindness resulted in...

Join our Newsletter for a FREE copy of Breaking Bad Habits e-Book by Ray